Granite vs. Quartz Countertops

Quartz and granite countertops are frequently discussed among homeowners, who often debate their differences as countertop materials when deciding which to choose for their homes. But is one countertop material truly better than the other, or is it purely a matter of appearance? 

Our team at Baker Bros has compiled this comprehensive guide to help you unravel the granite vs. quartz countertop conundrum. This blog highlights the differences between granite and quartz countertops and helps you choose the best countertop material for your project. 

What Are Quartz and Granite?

Before you can even begin to decide between the two, you need to know more about what these materials are. Let’s take a closer look: 

What is Quartz?

Quartz is a man-made stone that is not 100% natural. Instead, it is manufactured using about five percent polymer resins and about 95 percent ground natural quartz. A durable resin holds this material together and is often made with a small number of colorants and minerals. Quartz is usually confused with granite, but although they look somewhat similar, they are not the same material. 

What is Granite?

Granite is a 100 percent natural stone. It is mined from quarries worldwide and is available in several naturally occurring colors and patterns. Unlike quartz, granite's coloring is gifted by Mother Nature herself, meaning that every piece of granite has different veining patterns, coloration, and inconsistencies that make it beautiful. 

The Differences Between Quartz and Granite Countertops

When comparing granite vs quartz countertops, it is important to know what makes one different from the other. This is especially true if you plan to use your chosen material in your kitchen, which is a focal point of your home. To help you make a more informed decision about which material is best, we’ve listed their differences below: 

Maintenance

Granite Countertops

Granite countertops are generally considered low maintenance, but there is one pesky maintenance routine you’ll need to undertake annually—sealing. 

Annual sealing is a must if you want your granite countertops to maintain their stunning appeal. This process safeguards the semi-porous surface against scratching and staining. 

For similar reasons, keeping it clean with soap and water is crucial; however, you must avoid using harsh all-purpose cleaners or chemical cleaners on granite if you don’t want to damage it.

Quartz Countertops

Quartz countertop maintenance is nearly non-existent, which is unsurprising considering the material is man-made. 

But why doesn’t it require much maintenance? Well, to put it simply, the polymer resin creates a non-porous surface that resists stains and requires no attention or sealing to maintain its appearance. 

However, quartz is not infallible. In rare instances, the caulking where the wall meets the countertop may need to be replaced or refreshed, and heavy blows can break this stone.

Durability

Granite Countertops

Granite is a durable, heat-resistant, porous material. Due to its porosity, granite cannot resist staining like other countertop materials. However, it is incredibly durable. 

On average, granite countertops have a lifespan of about 100 years when well maintained and cared for appropriately. So, it's safe to say that your granite countertops might outlive you or survive multiple sales. 

Quartz Countertops

Quartz is a naturally formed stone that is engineered, so it is harder and more durable than granite. It isn’t porous and is less likely to chip or crack than granite, but it isn’t quite as durable as granite since heat can damage it. On average, a quartz countertop can last anywhere from 10 years to a lifetime, depending on how you look after it.  

Design Choices

Quartz Countertops

Quartz countertops offer a variety of design choices. Stores like Baker Bros sell everything from prefabricated quartz slabs in various colors and patterns to custom-designed, purpose-built masterpieces. 

Granite Countertops

Granite designs aren't created; they are chosen. Due to the abundance of readily available granite, these countertops come in an array of patterns and colors. So, for the most part, each countertop is a one-of-a-kind design! 

But—and we hate to say this—there is a downside to how much choice you have. The downside is that you may need to compromise or even shop around to find a kitchen countertop to match your desired look.

Price

How Much Does Granite Cost?

Based on information from HomeAdvisor.com, the average granite purchase and installation cost can range from $2,000 to $4,000. Yet you can save money by doing some preliminary work yourself and buying the material through a wholesaler like Baker Bros. 

However, it is important to understand that fabricating and installing granite countertops should always be left to the experts. You don’t want to try DIYing your granite installation and making mistakes that will cost you even more money down the line.

How Much Does Quartz Cost?

The cost of quartz varies depending on the style of the edging and the quartz quality. Information from HomeAdvisor.com estimates that the average cost to install quartz kitchen countertops can range from $3,000 to $7,500. It's pricey but worth it!

You could undertake some preliminary work to save money and offset costs; however, engineered quartz stone is heavier than other stone surfaces, so installing it can be challenging. 

That’s why it's always best to have an expert installer ensure the space where you want to install your kitchen countertop is structurally sound and will not collapse under the weight of the countertop.

Environmental Impacts: Quartz vs. Granite

When choosing between quartz and granite countertops, you also need to consider their environmental impacts. Unfortunately, there is no easy answer as to whether one is more eco-friendly than the other because both have positives and negatives. 

For example, quartz countertops could be better for the environment because they can often be locally sourced, while granite has to be sourced at the location where it is found. On the other hand, granite doesn’t have manufactured resins added to its composition since it is natural, making quartz more harmful to the environment in this regard. 

So, with this in mind, you will need to make your own decision about which you believe to be the better choice for the environment and your home. 

Contact a Flooring Expert to Find the Right Countertop for You 

Deciding between quartz and granite countertops is no easy feat, considering both are attractive choices. At the end of the day, your decision will be based on which you prefer and your budget and requirements, as both are top material choices for the kitchen. 

We hope we’ve provided you with enough information to help you decide. However, if you want more insights or to see the materials with your own eyes, you can visit us at Baker Bros. We have everything from natural to engineered stone countertops and can help you match your kitchen countertop with your existing or newly renovated design.