Luxury Vinyl vs. Hardwood Flooring: Which One’s Right for Your Home?

Choosing new flooring isn’t just a style decision—it’s a long-term investment in your home. When comparing luxury vinyl vs. hardwood flooring, there’s a lot to consider: durability, look, maintenance, and how it all fits your lifestyle. Whether you’re going for timeless charm or modern resilience, both flooring types have a lot to offer.

So, how do you decide between hardwood flooring vs. luxury vinyl? Let’s break it down.

Appearance: Real Wood vs. Real Good Imitations

Nothing quite beats the natural beauty of solid hardwood. The grain patterns, color variation, and overall warmth of real wood bring an organic, timeless appeal to any space. From rich walnuts to light maples, wood flooring never goes out of style.

On the other hand, luxury vinyl plank (LVP) has come a long way. Thanks to high-resolution imaging and multiple layers of construction, many vinyl plank flooring options are nearly indistinguishable from solid wood. And unlike wood, LVP won’t expand, contract, or scratch nearly as easily.

Winner: Tie. Choose hardwood for authentic character, or luxury vinyl for realistic visuals with low maintenance.

Durability & Wear Layer: Who Can Handle Life’s Messes?

Real solid hardwood is strong, but it’s not invincible. Pets, kids, high heels—over time, they leave a mark. The good news? Hardwood can be refinished multiple times, giving it a fresh start without needing a full replacement. And if it’s just light wear and tear, you may be able to fix scratches on your hardwood floors with a simple touch-up.

Luxury vinyl’s got a secret weapon: the wear layer. This clear top coating protects the floor from scratches, dents, and everyday abuse. And because LVP is water resistant (and in many cases waterproof), it’s a no-brainer for kitchens, bathrooms, and high traffic areas.

Winner: Luxury vinyl. It holds up better against water, wear, and busy households.

Water Resistance: Splashes, Spills, and Surprises

Here’s where luxury vinyl plank really shines. Unlike solid hardwood or even engineered hardwood, vinyl flooring is built to resist water damage. Thanks to its multiple layers, LVP won’t warp or swell when exposed to moisture, making it ideal for Arizona families battling spills, pets, or poolside drips.

Hardwood? Not so much. Even a small water mishap can leave lasting damage. Yes, some engineered options fare better, but they still don’t match vinyl’s defense against moisture.

Winner: Luxury vinyl. Especially in areas prone to moisture, like kitchens, bathrooms, and basements.

Comfort & Sound: How Do They Feel Underfoot?

Hardwood has that signature feel—solid, grounded, and a little warm. And with area rugs or underlayment, it can be surprisingly cozy.

Luxury vinyl can feel a little firmer, but newer planks often come with padded backing to improve comfort and reduce noise. It’s great if you’ve got a full house and want to soften the sound of footsteps.

Winner: Depends on preference. Hardwood feels more natural, while vinyl offers a practical, quieter underfoot experience—especially in busy households.

Maintenance: Easy to Clean vs. Easy to Stain

Both flooring types are easy to clean, but vinyl gets the edge for low-maintenance living. You can mop it, vacuum it, and forget it. There’s no need for waxing, polishing, or special cleaners.

Hardwood flooring, while still relatively simple to care for, does demand a little more attention. You’ll want to use wood-safe products and avoid too much moisture to protect the finish.

Winner: Luxury vinyl. It’s tough and hassle-free.

Cost: Square Foot, Big Difference

Let’s talk numbers. The cost per square foot varies widely depending on the product and brand, but in general, luxury vinyl plank comes in significantly cheaper than solid hardwood or even engineered hardwood. Plus, installation costs for vinyl are often lower, especially with click-lock systems.

Hardwood is an investment—and a beautiful one—but it’s not always ideal for budget-conscious homeowners.

Winner: Luxury vinyl. It delivers a high-end look for less.

Longevity & Resale Value: Built to Last?

Here’s where hardwood regains its footing. When well-maintained, hardwood flooring can last decades, and it can increase the resale value of your home. Buyers often associate natural wood with quality and craftsmanship.

Luxury vinyl lasts 10–20 years, depending on quality and wear, but it typically doesn’t boost home value in the same way.

Winner: Hardwood flooring. For long-term ROI, real wood still reigns.

So…Luxury Vinyl or Hardwood?

Still debating luxury vinyl vs. hardwood flooring? The answer depends on your priorities.

Choose luxury vinyl plank if you:

• Need a water-resistant option for kitchens, baths, or basements
• Have pets, kids, or heavy foot traffic
• Want a high-end look without the high-end price
• Prefer flooring that’s easy to clean and low maintenance

Choose hardwood flooring if you:

• Want the warmth and authenticity of natural wood
• Are planning to stay in your home long-term
• Want floors that can be refinished multiple times
• Are looking to increase the resale value of your home
  

Still not sure? That’s what we’re here for. At Baker Bros, our flooring experts can help you compare products side by side—so you can see, touch, and feel the difference. Plus, we offer expert installation and guidance at every step of your project.

Ready to explore your options? Visit a Baker Bros showroom near you and let’s find the perfect flooring for your home, your style, and your life.