Wondering When to Replace Your Carpet? Here’s 6 Signs It’s Time to Replace It

Summary

Carpet is cozy, comfortable, and adds warmth to any home, but even the highest-quality carpet doesn’t last forever. From carpet stains that won’t come out to heavy wear and tear in high traffic areas, knowing when to replace your carpet saves you time, money, and frustration.

On average, most carpets last 8–10 years, depending on the carpet pad, foot traffic, and how well you keep up with professional cleaning. At Baker Bros, we carry top brands like Karastan Carpet, known for durability and timeless style. Here are six signs it’s time to consider a carpet upgrade.

1. Stubborn Carpet Stains That Won’t Come Out

Even with a professional carpet cleaner, some carpet stains are permanent. If spills, pet accidents, or water damage leave behind discoloration, it may be time to replace your carpet.

2. Matting and Wear in High Traffic Areas

Over time, foot traffic in hallways, stairs, and living rooms flattens carpet fibers. If your carpet no longer bounces back, even after cleaning, it’s a sign that replacement is needed.

3. Lingering Odors You Can’t Remove

If odors from pets, moisture, or everyday life stick around even after professional cleaning, the smell has likely penetrated the carpet pad. At this point, replacement is the only solution.

4. Carpet Age: 8–10 Years is the Limit

How long does carpet last? Most quality carpets last for about a decade. If yours is pushing past 10 years, it’s probably showing multiple signs of wear and should be replaced.

5. Worn-Out Carpet Pad

The carpet pad underneath provides cushioning and insulation. If it’s worn down, you’ll notice uneven spots, wrinkles, or noise when you walk. A new carpet pad (and carpet) restores comfort and longevity.

6. Allergies or Dust Build-Up

Old carpet traps allergens, dust, and dirt deep in the fibers. If you notice increased allergy symptoms or more frequent sneezing, it’s time to replace your carpet for better indoor air quality.

Spotlight on Karastan Carpet

When considering replacement, Karastan Carpet is a standout option. Known for craftsmanship and durability, Karastan offers luxurious textures and patterns that hold up beautifully against daily wear and tear. Available at Baker Bros, it’s a smart choice for homeowners who want both style and longevity.

Our Most Common Questions 

Q: How long does carpet usually last?
A: Most carpets last 8–10 years, but high traffic areas or heavy use may shorten that lifespan.

Q: Can I extend the life of my carpet?
A: Yes! Regular vacuuming, professional cleaning, and rotating furniture can reduce wear and tear.

Q: Do I need to replace the carpet pad, too?
A: In most cases, yes. A new carpet pad ensures comfort, support, and lengthens your carpet's life.

Knowing when to replace carpet comes down to spotting the warning signs: permanent carpet stains, flattening in high traffic areas, odors, and aging fibers. Carpets typically last around 8–10 years, but your home’s unique level of foot traffic and wear and tear may shorten that timeline.

Time for a Refresh?

If you’ve spotted any of these six signs, it’s probably time to replace your carpet. From stubborn stains to aging fibers, a new carpet will instantly refresh your home.

At Baker Bros, we offer expert installation, premium selections like Karastan Carpet, and guidance to help you find the perfect fit for your lifestyle.

Visit a Baker Bros showroom near you and explore our wide selection of carpets to bring comfort and beauty back into your home.